http://www.suzannecollinsbooks.com |
From the beginning I felt that the Hunger Games movie was rushed and didn't give you the chance to think about it. In the book it describes District 12 filled with coal miners, black cinder streets and squat gray houses. (page 4) In the movie it seemed more like District 12 was were homeless people would go. As well as how the movie began. In the beginning of the movie they jumped to an interview between one one the game makers, while the book begins with Katniss walking up describing how Prim's cat is the world's ugliest cat. From leaving out the scene were "Haymitch ... appears hollering something unintelligible, staggers onto the stage and falls into the third chair." (page 19) to where Prim's name was called from the reaping, leaving Haymitch out when he said,"Look at her. Look at thus one..."(page 24)
http://blog.zooppa.com |
In the book they waited until the middle of the movie to mention the flashback when Peeta gave Katniss some burnt bread. On page 30 it was mention right after Peeta's name was drawn for the reaping. Originally Madge visited Katniss and gave her a mocking jay pin.(page 38) Although, in the movie Katniss got it in the Hob, gave it to Prim for luck, in return after Katniss volunteered, Prim gave it back to her. Then again during the last visit before Katniss went to the Capital Gale visited her. "I won't! You know I won't! Katniss remember I --" Gale says, and they yank us apart and slam the door and I'll never know what it was he wanted me to remember.(page 40) But again in the movie they left that part out.
In chapters 9-10 was when the 24 tributes had their own interview with Caesar. The book made it seem like all 24 tributes were on the stage but when it was their turn they would go up to the chair next to Caesar. When Peeta admitted he had a crush on Katniss the book described, I allow my eyes to flicker up to the screen long enough to see that the blush on my cheeks is unmistakable...I have to raise my head out of the require respect and cannot avoid seeing that every screen is now dominated by a shot of Peeta and me.. However in the movie Katniss was back stage and you didn't get to see that. Just simply things such as when Katniss and Peeta are in the elevator alone and she pushed Peeta into an urn with flowers that cut his hands, while in the movie she still shoved Peeta but it was in hall with Haymitch, Effie and Cinna really leave out expected scenes. After the Hunger Games began Katniss ran to an orange backpack. At that point a boy was there and coughed blood up on her. The movie just showed Katniss running into the boy but nothing about coughing up blood.
As well as some of the characters behaviors. Haymitch appears as if he would always be holding some kind of alcohol and calling Katniss 'Sweetheart' all the time after reading the book but it was almost the opposite in the movie. The way the book described him as being grumpy, mean spirited and rude, when the movie made him seem just unhappy at the beginning but then pretty much no strong emotions for the rest of the movie. Just like Cinna. Katniss expressed the she felt normal being with Cinna because of the way he didn't have as odd of outfits like the rest of the Capital and became her friend. Where Cinna gave her the pin back saying she left it on the train and events like the closeness between the two of them.
http://amandla-stenburg.tumblr.com/ |
http://imgfave.com/search/gale |
Honestly I enjoyed the Hunger Games book over the movie. The movie left out what I think were some of the most important parts. Although I know if they added every little detail it would be a four hour movie, I still would had appreciated if they slowed it down instead of rushing through the movie. What I think the best thing about the book was being able to understand Katniss thoughts and how she felt, in the movie there was nothing about that. I know it's hard to make a good movie adding in everyone's thoughts, that it is a lot easier to do in a book, but I think it would have enhanced the overall movie. Still the movie was fun to see how they would do certain parts such as when Peeta and Katniss were going to be on fire. The movie was a disappointment but hopefully if they make a movie about Catching Fire it will be similar to the book.
I agree with you that they left out a lot of very important parts, in my blog post and in yours. In the movie she buys the Mockingjay pin, but in the book Madge gives it to her. I don't know why they changed that and it definitely lowered the over all quality of the movie. But I thought the movie was good, even though there were some flaws. This was another amazing post, great job!
ReplyDelete